I think about what
we could have been if you had stayed
As I look into your eyes then turn my head away

Everything happened so fast
I think of my stupidity
As I think about our past

Why did you have to leave?
Why did you make me make-believe?
That what we had was real love
I thought I couldn't get enough

But then you announced the end
Causing pain
I cannot mend

It's true I'm an imbecile
I thought what we had was for real

Why did you have to leave?
Why did you make me make-believe?
That what we had was real love
I thought I couldn't get enough

Don't you realize what we had
Oh my, now I'm always mad

Can't you hear my malicious tone
As I sit here all alone

Why did you have to leave?
Why did you make me make-believe?
That what we had was real love
I thought I couldn't get enough