(Ray Pennington - Sonny Thompson - Ray Starr)

Three hearts in a tangle
One heart will have to break.

Tonight as I sit by my window
Watching the people go by
I'm trying to reach a decision
But I know I can't do what's right.

Three hearts in a tangle
Which heart should I take
Three hearts in a tangle
Which heart will I break.

--- Instrumental ---

If I choose the one that I should choose
Then the other heart would break
But if I'll leave them both then I'd suffer
Which heart will pay for my mistake.

Three hearts in a tangle
Which heart should I take
Three hearts in a tangle
Which heart will I break...